Dynamic Chiropractic
June 14, 1999, Volume 17, Issue 13
Upper Extremity Injuries in the Trucking Industry
by Randell Dobbs,DC, and Scott
Bjerkness,DC
Everyone knows that long haul
truck drivers suffer from low back pain. I was surprised to
discover during my nearly four years as a truck stop
chiropractor that many truck drivers also suffer from injuries
to the upper extremities. These upper extremity injuries seemed
so prevalent that I became curious about them. Just how many
truck drivers suffer from those upper extremities and why? To
answer these questions for myself, I conducted a records-based
study. I'm writing this article to present my findings to other
interested chiropractors.
There are approximately eight
million commercially licensed drivers in the United States. Of
this number, approximately 2.5 million are long haul truck
drivers. The long haul truck drivers are usually the ones that
find their way to my office, and so they are the group I
considered for my study. It's logical to assume that this group
of drivers will have a higher degree of work related injuries
than short haul drivers, due to their long hours in the truck
and less than ideal living circumstances. The trucking lifestyle
does not allow for easy access to chiropractors and other health
care providers. Consequently, many injured drivers never obtain
the treatment they need.
Two hundred patient files were
chosen at random. All of these patients were long haul truck
drivers. Of the 200 drivers studied, 111 (55%) presented with
upper extremity complaints. Of the 111 injured drivers, 93 were
male and 18 female. The study included 160 males and 40 females,
allowing us to calculate that 45% of the female drivers and 58%
of the male drivers presented with upper extremity injuries.
This data clearly shows that the lower back is not the only
region of the truck driver's body prone to injury.
The 111 upper extremity
complaints can be broken down to single and multiple areas of
complaint. Forty-nine of the 111 patients had multiple areas of
complaint, with a high prevalence of scapula and shoulder pain,
arm and hand tingling. I find this statistic alarming.
The likely causes of these
extremely prevalent injuries include: pulling the fifth wheel
pin; lowering and raising heavy truck hoods; slipping while
exiting the truck; sleeping on one's side in a bouncing vehicle;
lowering the landing gear; unloading trucks; driving with one
elbow supported on the window frame; and habitually resting the
hand on a constantly vibrating gearshift lever.
Some explanation is needed. The
fifth wheel pin is a heavy metal pin that fastens the truck
tractor to the trailer. To disengage the tractor from the
trailer, the driver must lean underneath the trailer on top of
the wheels and pull up and outward on the pin. This pin can be
extremely difficult to remove, and the position required to do
so is one of mechanical disadvantage. Anterior/inferior
subluxations of the humeral head and supraspinatus rotator cuff
damage are common injuries correlated with this behavior.
Lateral epicondylitis and medial epicondylitis are also common
resulting injuries.
The engine hood of an 18-wheel
truck is both high off the ground and heavy. The average truck
hood weighs approximately 300 pounds. To raise the hood, the
driver stands on the front bumper and leans his/her body weight
on the handle. Naturally, this would put strain on the upper
extremities.
Slipping on the truck step and
grabbing the hand bar to break a fall, is among the most common
causes of upper extremity injury to truck drivers. The rotator
cuff, elbow and A/C joint are damaged during this type of fall.
Team drivers live in a
constantly moving vehicle. One driver is often sleeping on the
bunk behind the seats while the other drives. The bunk is not
wide, but the trucker often is, making a side posture the only
comfortable position for sleep. Often the head is resting on the
extended arm. A moving truck not only vibrates but bounces.
Impact trauma to the vulnerable shoulder of the relaxed and
sleeping victim is common. Arkansas, Louisiana and Tennessee
seem to have roads that are especially likely to cause injury in
this manner. I'm tempted to mail thank you letters to the
governors of these states for sending me so much business.
Truckers refer to the support
legs on the trailer as landing gear, since they must be lowered
to disengage from the tractor and raised to haul the trailer.
This raising and lowering is accomplished by means of a hand
crank. This action causes repetitive stress-type injuries, most
often to the elbow and wrist. Any driver who was once a yard dog
(a worker in a truck yard responsible for swapping trailers
between trucks) seems to have a greater propensity for elbow and
wrist injury.
Unloading a truck is
self-explanatory. All kinds of injuries are likely to occur to a
sedentary, out of shape driver who has to "lump" or
"fingerprint" (trucker-speak for handling) a load.
Postural habits, such as leaning
the left elbow on the window frame or resting the hand or wrist
on the gear shift lever, expose the extremities to injury.
All of the above behaviors cause
injuries. Truck drivers are likely to engage in several, if not
all, of the behaviors every day of their working lives. It's
only a matter of time until the upper extremities become
symptomatic. Educating truck drivers on the dangers of such
injuries seems to be a fairly effective approach. Health care
providers must be on the lookout for upper extremity injuries in
their truck driving patients, who may not complain about their
injuries even though they are in pain. Many people still believe
that chiropractors only treat the spine, and they fail to
mention other troublesome areas during an exam.
If a truck driver walks into
your office, examine the upper extremities. Treating injuries
early is always better than waiting until the patient can't
perform the job. Truck drivers are very important to our way of
life. Everything you buy at a store or use daily is brought to
you via a truck. Keeping truck drivers on the road is good for
them -- and for the rest of us.
|